Home > newsroom > Page
Tax Extenders & Cobell Indian Settlement

WASHINGTON, D.C., May 24, 2010 -

Read the full Dear Colleague HERE.

May 24, 2010

Amendment to Tax Extenders Bill
Aims to Improve Cobell Indian Settlement Agreement

Reflects five improvements sought by Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians
(AK, CA, ID, MT, OR and WA)

Dear Colleague:
                Today I filed an amendment with the Rules Committee to H.R. 4213, the tax extenders legislation, to improve section 607, which authorizes the proposed Cobell v. Salazar Class Action Settlement Agreement.  My amendment reflects five key areas in need of improvement that were identified in a resolution adopted by the Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians.  This organization represents more than 50 federally recognized tribes in Oregon, Idaho, Washington, southeast Alaska, northern California, and western Montana.
                The principle improvement made by my amendment is to put a cap on attorney fees – which, unless Congress acts, could exceed $100 million.  By capping attorney fees at $50 million, as my amendment would do, this allows the $50 million saved to increase payments to individual Indians.  Currently, every dollar paid to attorneys is a dollar taken out of the pockets of individual Indian claimants.
                Other improvements made by my Amendment are described more fully below.
                I would appreciate your support for increasing benefits for individual Indians without increasing the overall cost of the settlement proposal.


Doc Hastings
Ranking Member
Committee on Natural Resources

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE                       CONTACT:           Jill Strait or Spencer Pederson
Monday, May 24, 2010                                                                                           202-226-2311

Hastings to Introduce Amendment to “Tax Extenders Bill” to Improve Cobell Settlement
Amendment will cap attorney fees, increase payments to individual Indians

WASHINGTON D.C. – House Natural Resources Committee Ranking Member Doc Hastings (WA-04) will introduce an amendment today to fix and improve the proposed Cobell v. Salazar settlement agreement included in the Democrats’ tax extender package (H.R. 4213). Hastings’ amendment will include five improvements to benefit individual Indians affected by the proposed settlement.

The Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians (ATNI), an organization representing more than 50 federally recognized tribes adopted a resolution on May 20, 2010 supporting the five improvements first outlined in an April letter to tribal leaders from Senator John Barrasso(R-WY), the Vice Chairman of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee. ATNI represents tribes in Washington, Idaho, Oregon, Montana, Nevada, Northern California, and Alaska. ATNI specifically requested “that Congress take whatever steps [are] necessary to ensure that they are incorporated prior to passage of the settlement by the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate.”

Each of these five improvements would directly benefit individual Indians and ensure they receive the most from this settlement,” said House Natural Resources Committee Ranking Member Doc Hastings. Considering the number of questions and concerns expressed by Indians about this proposed settlement, Congress has a responsibility to act on their behalf and make these improvements.

“One change that must be made is to limit the high level of attorney fees that could exceed $100 million. The bottom-line is that every dollar paid to attorneys is a dollar that comes out of the pocket of individual Indians.

“Assertions have been made that changing just one sentence in this proposed settlement would terminate it. The reality is that changes have already been made and deadlines have already been extended. The only way this agreement dissolves is if the parties involved choose to walk away. This amendment makes improvements to ensure individual Indians, not lawyers, receive the most money possible. This is something that all parties involved and all Members of Congress should be able and willing to support.”

Hastings’ amendment will include the following five improvements to the proposed Cobell settlement agreement:

1. Cap attorney fees at $50 million and use the savings to increase the payments checks provided under the settlement to hundreds of thousands of individual Indians.

2. Limit “incentive awards” for the Named Plaintiffs to actual, unreimbursed out-of-pocket expenses incurred by those plaintiffs – this also ensures the greatest amount of the settlement goes to the hundreds of thousands of individual Indians.

3. Ensure that the Court selects a safe, experienced, qualified bank to hold the $1.4 billion in settlement funds, and that the bank is independent of the Named Plaintiffs and their attorneys. This eliminates any conflict of interest and ensures the security of the funds.

4. Provide that money “saved” by reducing attorneys fees by $50 million may be set aside in a special fund to increase settlement payments to individual Indian damages claimants. This corrects a subtle but major flaw in the payment formulas developed by the Plaintiffs and the Obama Administration.

5. Require the Department of the Interior to consult with Indian tribes in planning, designing, and setting the priorities for the $2 billion fractional interest acquisition program under the settlement, and allow tribes the opportunity to compact or contract with the Department to implement this program.


Under the proposed agreement announced by the Obama Administration, $1.4 billion would go towards more than 300,000 individual Indians to resolve historical accounting claims, and to establish and settle a new class of claims relating to resource mismanagement, which were not part of the Cobell lawsuit. In addition, $2 billion will be made available to the Secretary of the Interior for the purpose of acquiring highly fractionated Indian lands under current Indian land consolidation laws, to fund an Indian scholarship fund, and for a Secretarial Commission on trust reform.

Ranking Member Hastings recently sent a letter to Dennis Gingold, a plaintiff attorney in the Cobell v. Salazar settlement agreement, regarding statements made in the news media that the proposed settlement will be terminated if Congress does not approve the agreement by May 28, 2010 or attempts to change any part of it – including putting a cap on attorneys’ fees that could exceed $100 million.

Click here for more information on the proposed Cobell v. Salazar settlement.

# # #


Facebook | YouTube | Twitter

Read the full Dear Colleague HERE.

Latest News

Bishop Statement on Antiquities Act Executive Order

House Committee on Natural Resources Chairman Rob Bishop (R-UT) issued the following statement in reaction to President Trump’s announcement on national monument designations. “Today’s action sends th...... Read more

Bishop Opening Statement on Markup: Infrastructure Proposals to Advance

Live Webcast: Click HERE. Remarks as prepared for delivery: “Today, the Committee will consider a range of bills to protect and improve our nation’s water and power infrastructure, spur job creation a...... Read more

Bishop Statement on Confirmation of Sonny Perdue as Agriculture Secretary

Today, Chairman Rob Bishop (R-UT) issued the following statement after the U.S. Senate voted to confirm Sonny Perdue as Secretary of the Department of Agriculture: “I congratulate Secretary Perdue on ...... Read more

View All News


Full Committee Markup
Full Committee | 1324 Longworth House Office Building Washington D.C. 20515
Oversight Hearing on Examining the Consequences of Executive Overreach of the Antiquities Act
Subcommittee on Federal Lands | 1324 Longworth House Office Building Washington D.C. 20515
Oversight Hearing on The Challenges of Keeping Hydropower Affordable and Opportunities for New Development
Subcommittee on Water, Power and Oceans | 1324 Longworth House Office Building Washington D.C. 20515
View All Events